Best Property Managers
in Chico

We evaluated property portfolios, tenant feedback, and management expertise to find the best property managers in Chico.

✓ Property Managers Verified Updated September 2026 · 5 locations ranked

Quick Overview

# Location Name Expertise Rating Authority Score
1 Hignell Rentals
1750 Humboldt Rd, Chico, CA 95928
Property Management
★ ★ ★ ☆ ☆
3.8
75.17
2 Blue Oak Property Management Inc
2889 Cohasset Rd Ste 5, Chico, CA 95973
Property Management
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.4
74.19
3 Entwood Property Management
2515 Ceanothus Ave #100, Chico, CA 95973
Property Managers
★ ★ ★ ☆ ☆
3.5
71.99
4 The Hignell Companies
1750 Humboldt Rd, Chico, CA 95928
Property Management
★ ★ ★ ☆ ☆
3.8
71.69
5 Countryside Property Management
2233 Nord Ave Ste 3, Chico, CA 95926
Trusted Manager
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
5.0
59.63

Expert Reviews

Hignell Rentals
Property Management
1
Hignell Rentals
75.17
Authority
1750 Humboldt Rd, Chico, CA 95928

Hignell Rentals at 1750 Humboldt Road in Chico offers a setting with numerous mature trees and a variety of amenities including a pool, clubhouse, and tennis courts. Residents report a positive experience with staff, noting responsiveness to issues such as plumbing repairs handled by individuals like Mars and Mickey. The property's upkeep is generally maintained, with visible efforts in areas like the pool and barbecue facilities.

The complex features community gardens and dedicated dog play areas, contributing to resident engagement. A long-term resident of 23 years has observed property upgrades over the past five years. While the grounds are frequently described as clean and well-groomed, there are instances where specific maintenance issues, like reported water leaks or tree branch concerns, may take an extended period for correction.

Proximity to local shopping and the mall is a noted advantage of the location. However, internet connectivity options may be limited to a single provider, impacting online activities and communication. Despite this, many residents find the apartments to be comfortable and well-equipped for daily living.

Blue Oak Property Management Inc
Property Management
2
Blue Oak Property Management Inc
74.19
Authority
2889 Cohasset Rd Ste 5, Chico, CA 95973

Blue Oak Property Management's maintenance team received specific commendation, particularly from one resident who noted Pete's prompt, professional, and communicative approach to a toilet leak. This resident expressed hope for Pete's continued involvement with future issues, citing his helpfulness and professionalism as a positive experience.

Other tenant experiences present a different perspective. One account details significant issues upon moving into a property in May 2026, including an unclean home, a locked garage door with no keys, a stuck back door, malfunctioning stove burners, a loose ceiling fan, and broken blinds. The property manager, Ariel, was described as unprofessional, lacking communication skills, and assigning blame for these problems.

A separate tenant's account highlights a severe lack of support in a dangerous living situation, where an assault occurred and Blue Oak Property Management reportedly refused assistance without police involvement, and even then, failed to take action to ensure the tenant's safety. This individual strongly advised against renting with the company, citing unhelpful management with a negative attitude and a focus on profit.

Entwood Property Management
Property Managers
3
Entwood Property Management
71.99
Authority
2515 Ceanothus Ave #100, Chico, CA 95973

Entwood Property Management's operational practices presented a significant challenge for one tenant. Issues with property condition upon lease takeover included a noted roach problem, requiring self-treatment, and persistent malfunctions with the air conditioning system. Separating floorboards and deteriorating blinds also contributed to ongoing habitability concerns. The management communicated that the property was being sold, leading to frequent showings and professional photography featuring the tenant's belongings. This created an environment where the tenant felt pressured to vacate, only to discover the property was subsequently relisted for rent at a previously discussed renewal rate. Post-move-out charges for items like non-matching light bulbs and pre-existing damage were levied, contributing to a feeling of being misled regarding the property's sale status.

Conversely, another renter experienced prompt maintenance responses and regular upkeep of communal areas such as the pool during a two-year tenancy. Office staff provided timely and courteous assistance with inquiries. A separate resident found representative Sabrina to be consistently helpful and communicative regarding lease information and concerns, noting her ability to address both minor and major issues with impressive clarity.

Experiences with Entwood Property Management varied significantly, with one review detailing a move-in that was characterized by a lack of cleanliness, including pests and non-functional amenities. The reviewer reported difficulty in obtaining timely maintenance responses, with concerns often going unaddressed. Upon vacating, a substantial portion of the security deposit was withheld for cleaning and repairs, which the tenant disputed given the initial condition of the apartment. Another tenant expressed satisfaction with property manager Amanda, citing her flexibility in scheduling tours and her helpfulness in answering questions about utilities and the lease.

The Hignell Companies
Property Management
4
The Hignell Companies
71.69
Authority
1750 Humboldt Rd, Chico, CA 95928

The Hignell Companies' property management services have drawn mixed feedback. One account details a lack of clear communication regarding lease termination, requiring a follow-up call to a Redding office to resolve questions about month-to-month options versus a new lease term. This specific situation was ultimately clarified by an individual named Cheyenne.

Concerns have been raised regarding the conduct of a property manager who allegedly used communal amenities for personal use, with an armed guard reportedly offering apologies to residents for ongoing issues. Separately, a potential tenant experienced a significant time investment of four days, including two office visits and application submissions, to view a specific unit at 1217 W. Sacramento Ave - 114, only to find the listing removed without prior notification.

In contrast to these resident experiences, the Hignell Foundation has been recognized for its support of local education, contributing to Positive Educational Partnerships (PEP). This funding enabled the strengthening of Wellness Centers at several schools, providing students with dedicated spaces and resources for emotional regulation and a return to learning.

Countryside Property Management
Trusted Manager
5
Countryside Property Management
59.63
Authority
2233 Nord Ave Ste 3, Chico, CA 95926

Countryside Property Management, located at 2233 Nord Ave Ste 3 in Chico, California, manages residential properties. They oversee a portfolio that includes residences in locales described as "cute beach town areas."

The team's property management approach involves thorough inspections. Adam, a representative, conducted a detailed walkthrough with one client, addressing all questions and concerns raised. He took time to examine specific points of client apprehension during property inspections.

Their service includes follow-up regarding property condition. Countryside Property Management inquires about any existing issues requiring resolution.

Is something outdated?

Help us keep this list accurate

Business details change frequently. If you notice inaccurate information or a closed nursery or landscaping service, let us know and we'll update our rankings promptly.

Explore Nearby Cities

Looking for Real Estate Agents in Chico?

We've also ranked the best real estate agents in this city based on the same rigorous expertise scoring.

Explore Chico Real Estate Agents