Best Property Managers
in Orlando

We evaluated property portfolios, tenant feedback, and management expertise to find the best property managers in Orlando.

✓ Property Managers Verified Updated October 2026 · 5 locations ranked

Quick Overview

# Location Name Expertise Rating Authority Score
1 Atrium Management Company
201 S Bumby Ave, Orlando, FL 32803
Needs Improvement
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.4
88.72
2 Specialized Property Management Orlando Florida
122 W Pine St Suite 351, Orlando, FL 32801
Property Management
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.4
87.47
3 Verandah Properties, LLC
6900 Tavistock Lakes Blvd Ste 457, Orlando, FL 328...
Trusted Partner
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.8
87.21
4 Real Property Management South Orlando
5728 Major Blvd Suite 710, Orlando, FL 32819
Orlando Properties
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.7
87.20
5 TrustHome Properties
3837 N Econlockhatchee Trail, Orlando, FL 32817
Property Management
★ ★ ★ ★ ☆
4.4
87.06

Expert Reviews

Atrium Management Company
Needs Improvement
1
Atrium Management Company
88.72
Authority
201 S Bumby Ave, Orlando, FL 32803

Atrium Management Company, located at 201 S Bumby Ave, Orlando, FL 32803, appears to have a significant disconnect between stated intentions and resident experience. Reports detail issues ranging from the immediate aftermath of move-in, with homes found unprepared and lacking essential services like hot water or functional air conditioning, to ongoing maintenance problems. The process for reporting and resolving these issues has been described as cumbersome, with tickets closed prematurely and necessary repairs left unaddressed. This has resulted in residents incurring out-of-pocket expenses to make properties habitable.

Communication and accountability are recurring themes in resident feedback. Multiple accounts mention difficulty reaching management for timely responses, with phone calls going unanswered and issues being deferred. Delays in addressing safety and habitability concerns are attributed, in part, to a lengthy approval process involving overseas owners, a situation that underscores the critical role of a property manager in making prompt decisions. One account specifically notes that a formal notice was required to elicit a response and action from the company.

Furthermore, residents have reported financial disputes, including attempts to charge for pre-existing damages and the withholding of security deposits for items not sufficiently addressed or previously present. Infrastructure problems within managed properties have also been cited, leading to disruptions such as water service shutoffs and unaddressed humidity issues. The overall sentiment from these accounts suggests a pattern where resident needs and comfort are secondary to administrative processes.

Specialized Property Management Orlando Florida
Property Management
2
Specialized Property Management Orlando Florida
87.47
Authority
122 W Pine St Suite 351, Orlando, FL 32801

Specialized Property Management Orlando manages properties from their office at 122 W Pine St Suite 351. The firm facilitated a tenant move-in process, completing all necessary steps within two weeks of initial contact. For property owners, the team coordinates trades to address property issues and prepare residences for marketing.

Within the leasing division, an individual named Tatiana is noted for her support throughout the tenant move-out process. Another representative, Nancy, provided weekly updates covering property site visits, applicant submissions, and feedback from prospective tenants during a property listing.

Alfredo Quezada is recognized as a professional with extensive knowledge in his field. The company’s general operations involve responsive communication to resolve tenant issues.

Verandah Properties, LLC
Trusted Partner
3
Verandah Properties, LLC
87.21
Authority
6900 Tavistock Lakes Blvd Ste 457, Orlando, FL 32827

Verandah Properties, LLC operates from its Orlando office at 6900 Tavistock Lakes Blvd Ste 457. The firm has facilitated effective management of homes in the Lake Nona area, addressing tenant situations within a week for one client.

Pamela, a representative at Verandah Properties, has been noted for her professionalism, responsiveness, and thorough attention to detail. This level of diligence is also present in Megan's work, who has been instrumental in improving maintenance operations, leading to a 100% increase in communication and more efficient coordination.

Clients have reported a consistent ability to gain control of their properties with Verandah Properties' assistance. The team is accessible, providing timely answers to questions and adapting to individual operational needs.

Real Property Management South Orlando
Orlando Properties
4
Real Property Management South Orlando
87.20
Authority
5728 Major Blvd Suite 710, Orlando, FL 32819

Real Property Management South Orlando manages properties from its Orlando base at 5728 Major Blvd Suite 710. The company works with both property owners and renters, providing oversight for investments and facilitating rental experiences. The team's understanding of the local Orlando area distinguishes their service from national companies.

Specific team members have been noted for their engagement with clients. Leland Johnson's approach is described as facilitating smooth transitions, even extending to post-move-in support. Jared, identified as an owner, works with clients on securing tenants and refining lease terms, while Gabby, a property manager, handles listing generation, applicant inquiries, and showings. Both are recognized for their proactive communication and organization, particularly through a dedicated owner/tenant business portal.

The company's handling of maintenance requests is highlighted for its speed and efficiency. Beyond prompt issue resolution, the team’s responsiveness and consideration during challenging circumstances, such as unexpected personal events, have been noted. This combination of professional management and supportive interaction is a recurring theme in client feedback.

TrustHome Properties
Property Management
5
TrustHome Properties
87.06
Authority
3837 N Econlockhatchee Trail, Orlando, FL 32817

TrustHome Properties manages properties in Orlando, Florida. Dawn Slaughter has managed a condominium on Oyster Bay Circle for approximately eight years, providing timely information and counsel. Lydia Pisano facilitated a sale, characterized as swift and uncomplicated. Gloriluz and Susana have managed a rental home in the Solivita Community for several years, demonstrating consistent responsiveness and professionalism, with support from the firm's back office through regular financial reports.

The application and move-in processes have involved staff such as Michelle and Susana Canedo. Michelle is noted for her helpfulness and promptness during the application stages, with her colleagues also offering responsive support in her absence. Susana Canedo is described as understanding, professional, and prompt in assisting with initial applications. The firm's use of an AI bot for initial inquiries was not ideal for some, though direct interaction with staff members like Michelle facilitated a smooth transition.

Concerns have been raised regarding emergency response protocols. In one instance, an apartment lacked air conditioning for three days during Florida's summer heat, posing a health and safety risk to residents with young children. Despite multiple calls to management, a meaningful update or return call was not received for an extended period, even from ownership. This situation highlighted a perceived lack of available emergency or backup services for urgent resident needs.

Is something outdated?

Help us keep this list accurate

Business details change frequently. If you notice inaccurate information or a closed nursery or landscaping service, let us know and we'll update our rankings promptly.

Explore Nearby Cities

Explore Neighbourhoods in Orlando

Looking for Real Estate Agents in Orlando?

We've also ranked the best real estate agents in this city based on the same rigorous expertise scoring.

Explore Orlando Real Estate Agents