Best Property Managers in
New York

The state-wide leaderboard. We've aggregated data from across New York to find the absolute elite Property Managers destinations.

Average Authority Score
66.5
across all ranked locations
Top-Rated City
New York
highest avg. score in New York
Verified Locations
40
businesses confirmed active
Cities Ranked
2
New York · Rochester

New York Hall of Fame

Daisy property management
State Elite
1
Daisy property management
91.05
Authority
385 5th Ave, New York, NY 10016

Daisy property management has established itself as a premier destination for Property Managers services in New York. With years of practical horticultural experience, they serve the local community by transforming spaces and helping landscapes thrive in the regional climate.

Reviews highlight their high-quality work and professional communication. Clients appreciate their timely updates, expert plant suggestions, and clean execution. From small container gardens to extensive backyard turf redesigns, they consistently deliver attentive and detailed care.

In addition to core services, they prioritize eco-friendly and organic practices. Their selection includes rich organic soils, composts, and drought-resistant native plant varieties tailored for sustainability. This sustainable focus makes them a highly recommended provider for modern home gardeners.

ProRealty Property Management
State Elite
2
ProRealty Property Management
90.72
Authority
233 Monitor St, Brooklyn, NY 11222

ProRealty Property Management operates from 233 Monitor Street in Brooklyn. Their approach involves direct engagement with service providers, with individuals like Vince noted for consistently clear communication and timely follow-through on matters. This level of interaction facilitates smoother operations for external partners.

The company maintains multiple properties, with vendors such as Deekay Pest Control and Victor Fire Protection noting the team's commitment to standards. George, a point of contact, is recognized for responsiveness and attention to maintaining safe and comfortable environments for residents. This focus extends to proactive adherence to safety and security regulations across their managed buildings.

For vendors, ProRealty Property Management has a record of efficient communication and punctual payments, noted by a small business owner. This operational consistency allows for a straightforward working relationship with their contracted partners.

FirstService Residential Manhattan
State Elite
3
FirstService Residential Manhattan
89.66
Authority
575 5th Ave 9th Fl, New York, NY 10017

FirstService Residential Manhattan, located at 575 5th Ave, 9th Fl, New York, NY 10017, handles property management with a focus on application processing. The company assigns dedicated individuals to guide clients through purchase applications within cooperatives. One standout processor, Margoth Carvajal, is noted for her attentiveness, kindness, and promptness in answering questions, simplifying what can be a complex procedure for both buyers and brokers.

The application process itself can be lengthy, with some clients reporting durations of two months from initial contact to closing. While a digital portal is available, navigating the requirements and timelines can present challenges. However, the effectiveness of the process often hinges on the assigned individual. For instance, Margoth Carvajal is described as knowledgeable, responsive, and customer-oriented, significantly easing the experience for those who worked with her.

Gracie, another member of the FirstService Residential team, is frequently highlighted for her professionalism, efficiency, and meticulous attention to detail in managing applications. Her ability to expedite transactions while ensuring accuracy has earned her consistent praise from those who rely on her expertise for their transactions. Taqiyya Williams is also recognized for her responsiveness, clarity, and efficiency in handling application matters.

Retain Each Property Management
State Elite
4
Retain Each Property Management
87.38
Authority
3380 Monroe Ave Ste 207, Rochester, NY 14618

Retain Each Property Management in Rochester addresses property oversight with a structured approach. The company facilitates regular communication, with individuals like Donnie noted for consistent updates throughout client interactions. This consistent flow of information aids in managing expectations and maintaining awareness of ongoing property matters.

The team at Retain Each offers a degree of personalized attention. Kerry Ann provided detailed assistance, clarifying information and resolving client inquiries effectively. John also contributed a specific instance of helpfulness and a professional demeanor in client interactions.

A core element of Retain Each's operation involves a collaborative team effort. Annie, Kerry-Ann, Kahalia, Donnie, and Holly are among those who have been identified for thoroughness and helpfulness. This coordinated work across team members contributes to an overall sense of security for property owners.

Retain Each Property Management
State Elite
5
Retain Each Property Management
86.58
Authority
275 Lake Ave Ste 155, Rochester, NY 14608

Retain Each Property Management, located at 275 Lake Ave Ste 155 in Rochester, handles property management services. The company interacts with clients through its representatives.

Among its personnel, Kahalia assisted individuals through their home search and rental processes. She demonstrated patience and helpfulness during these interactions. Kelly also played a role in simplifying the rental experience for clients.

Property owners have noted the company's organized and transparent approach. Communication regarding property care and the overall rental process is maintained.

City Directory

Switch to Real Estate Agents in New York

We also track and rank the top real estate agents providers across New York.

View New York Real Estate Agents